441. Coming to Homerica

Coming to Homerica(originally aired May 17, 2009)
So chalk immigration up as one more hot button topic this show clearly can’t handle. This entire episode is so hamfisted and obvious with its points, once again to the point where characters are just flat-out expositing the plot and their changing viewpoints. The show chronicles Springfield’s experience with an influx of immigrants. From where? Neighboring city Ogdenville, whose populous nearly all got laid off following a tainted barley snafu. We’ve seen the Ogdenville Outlet Mall, and of course this is one of the towns Lyle Lanley swindled with his monorail scheme, but now the town is full of Norwegian-esque types, kindly, naive hired hands that the people of Springfield quickly take advantage of. Then we see problems that Springfielders basically create for themselves (Bart getting hurt on his skateboard trying to show up an Ogdenville kid, Homer getting fired for showing up drunk on Aquavit) are blamed on the Ogdenvillians. I know Springfield is filled with idiots, but they should still remain sympathetic and likable to an extent. Marge hands Maggie over to a nanny (why she wants a woman in to clean the house and take care of the baby, her two most valued things in life, is beyond me), and is horrified to find her first words are in “Ogdenvillese;” she kind of made her own bed on that one.

How do we stop Ogdevillians to get in? Set up a border patrol, of course, with the most slovenly, intolerant, idiotic folks imaginable, and their leader will be the dumbest of all… Homer, of course. So it’s like “Homer the Vigilante” again, except not really because there’s barely any screen time devoted to their exploits. All we get to see if that they’re incompetent, and compare their jingoistic outlook to the KKK and the Nazis. Way to be subtle, guys. What’s our grand end-all solution? Build a wall across the border, but because that’s too much work, we’ll have the Ogdenvillians help us do it. While building, we see the two sides talk to one another, and we see how they actually relate to each other and get along real well, in an embarrassingly on-the-nose sequence (even more so when Flanders blatantly says, “Maybe we’re not so different, Sven.”) They finish the wall, then the two sides make up and everybody’s fine. A real head-scratcher; everyone in Springfield is painted in such a bigoted, scornful light, and yet we have a big party at the end. It’s like when they make Homer an intolerable ass and expect you to still like him, but on some of these episodes, that disease has spread to the entire town. No, sir, I don’t like it.

Tidbits and Quotes
– More great “parodies,” as the Simpsons watch “The Drowningest Catch” on the Planet Channel. Though I did chuckle at the two guys being thrown overboard (“It was worth it to be on TV!” “Put our dying screams in the promo!”)
– Apu makes an appearance, because he can eat one of the new barley burgers as a Hindu, then he makes a silly Indian dance and leaves. Remember when Apu was actually a character outside being a convenience store clerk and from a foreign culture we can make fun of?
– So Ogdenville’s entire economy hinged on barley, and every single citizen was a barley farmer? They make things so exaggerated and one note nowadays that it’s impossible to take this kind of stuff seriously.
– So much on-the-nose dialogue (“You know, I’m glad you’ve come here to take all the jobs we don’t want to do. Can’t have too much of a good thing.” “This Ogdenville influx has been great for everybody!”)
– Homer shows up to work drunk, and gets fired. He then blames the Ogdenvillians for getting him drunk somehow. And Marge sympathizes (“Oh, poor Homey. And you with your alcoholism!”) I guess her being a spineless enabler is funny?
– Another Pixar reference as we see Carl’s flying house from Up float by behind Lenny and Carl. That’s really all it is, a reference, reminding me I could actually be watching far, far, faaaaaar better things than this piece of shit.

Season 20 Final Thoughts
And so, we reach the end of our final season. For almost an entire year, I’ve watched as this series I love so much has descended into that shallowest possible version of itself, and shockingly, it just keeps getting worse and worse each season. As such, season 20 boggled my mind. Boatloads of expository dialogue, inept attempts at humor, scatter shot characterization, the problems with these episodes are incredibly numerous. What shocked me was how many of these shows seemed so vacuous and devoid of anything really… happening. Things would happen in them, sure, but none of it seemed to really follow with any story or theme, or seem to have any purpose whatsoever. A lot of it just felt like twenty minutes of white noise. We’ve gone from the greatest show on television, and it’s been eaten away to… nothing. A show of just… nothing. I remember being quite beaten down after the run of HD shows when I first watched them. The thought of stopping had crossed my mind, but it was becoming more of a likely possibility after the finale. But I just wasn’t ready to quit. I’d give them another chance with season 21, I thought. However, as it turned out, my tenure would soon be up.

The Best
…yep, it finally happened. Out of the twenty-one episodes this season, I honestly can’t say I enjoyed any of them. That’s a good enough telltale sign that this would be my last season.

The Worst
“Mypods and Boomsticks,” “Lisa the Drama Queen,” “Take My Life, Please,” “How the Test Was Won,” “Wedding for Disaster”

13 responses to “441. Coming to Homerica

  1. More terrible episodes than classic ones at this point.

    And the ratio is only getting worse. 😦

  2. I’m surprised “No Loan Again, Naturally” isn’t on your worst list. That has to be one of the most mean-spirited and unpleasant episodes of any TV show.

  3. Only 3 more episodes left…
    Your torture is almost at an end.

  4. krikensworld.blogspot.com that guy did an amazing analysis on this episode plus on the nonsensical “satire” on immagrants as these people live in THE SAME FUCKING STATE as each other!!!! GRRRRRR! good thing you only have 3 episodes left Mike.

  5. I agree, Mike: Season 20 was a bust. I didn’t care for any of the episodes, which had never happened before this point. Even seasons 13-19, as mediocre as they were, at least had a handful of episodes per season that I didn’t mind re-watching. Not this time.

  6. populous > populace

  7. I still cannot believe you did not like Gone Maggie Gone.

    Anyway, I’m saddened because now I have no more episodes to read about and discuss 😦 As such, unless something pops up or I need to respond to something after this post, this is most likely my final post.

    As for this episode, I thought “Much Apu About Nothing” handled this material far far better.

  8. It’s depressing that they couldn’t have been more creative & created a new name for the town the Norwegians inhabited but, tragically, they weren’t & were lazy by referring to them as Ogdenvillians when in prior episodes, just like the “Shelbyville” in “The 7-beer Snitch” with its snooty upper-class citizens, it established this was NOT the case.

  9. I remember this episode aired the same night as the King of the Hill episode where Canadians move into Boomhauer’s house. I’m guessing someone at Fox wanted to make a statement about immigrants…

  10. The only thing I will say about this episode is that it had one line which made me laugh for featuring Homer being stupid and funny, as opposed to either stupid and mean or stupid and self destructive.

    “the real drowningest catch is man”

  11. The sad part is, some people having people build a wall to keep said people out is more relevant now than ever.

  12. The Simpsons handled immigration better in that one with the bear tax.

    Alternatively, “Goobacks from the Future” is am excellent take by South Park.

  13. What? How could Season 20 have no best episodes? I thought for sure you would love Sex, Pies and Idiot Scrapes. That was cool how Homer and Ned became bounty hunters. It was a very creative storyline. I can suspend disbelief for them suddenly knowing parkour.

Leave a Reply to Guy Incognito Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s